Skip to main content

On This Day in 1215

November 11 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia: "1215 - The fourth lateran council meets, adopting the doctrine of transubstantiation, meaning that bread and wine are transformed into the body and blood of Christ."
The doctrine of the eucharist was the most important issue during the 16th century Reformation. It caused more divisions between evangelicals than any other issue. At that time, other doctrines were proposed as responses to this doctrine:
  • Luther proposed the doctrine of consubstantiation. He used the allegory of a hot iron to demonstrate that, just as there is fire is in a hot iron but the fire does not become the iron, so Christ is present in the bread and wine but the elements do not become Christ.
  • Zwingli proposed a symbolic interpretation of the Last Supper, saying that there is no real presence in the elements.
  • Calvin proposed a doctrine of "spiritual presence," saying that the body and blood of Jesus Christ are received in a spiritual manner by faith (it is neither taken substantially, nor as a mere symbol).
Who do you agree with? Why? For those who say "Who cares?":
This statement by Jesus appears to have been taken literally by those who heard it, as the majority of those who heard it were shocked and left him. St. Paul implies an identity between the apparent bread and wine and the body and blood of Christ when he writes: "Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty of profaning the body and blood of the Lord." (1 Corinthians 11:27 )

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

And What Happens When I Don't Wait Well?

I guess you get anxious ... and we all know what that’s like. But I think that “ yakhal ” (Hebrew) or " elpis " (Greek) does not preclude the possibility of action - whether it’s writing about the situation, or something more (and don't underestimate the power of journaling!) Indeed, you don't think of prophets or apostles as the kind of people to sit around just waiting for something to happen. They act, but their action is tempered by the realization that things don’t look too good at the moment (otherwise why would the issue even be coming up?) So they act and wait at the same time, knowing that the fruits of their action are ultimately dependent on the Lord. And of course the Lord is known to have us do things for a while before any kind of clear result is made known. Like planting, and then watering, and then waiting, for a seed to turn into a plant. Farmers probably understand waiting a lot better than we do. They think in seasons and years, not months or we...
Post a Comment
Read more

God and Computers Webcast

"In the fall of 1999, computer scientist Donald E. Knuth was invited to give six public lectures at MIT on the general subject of relations between faith and science. The lectures were broadcast live on the Internet and watched regularly by tens of thousands of people around the world, and they have remained popular many months after the event." Information about the lectures in book form can be found here .
Post a Comment
Read more